JLSC INTRA-FORUM CONTEST #4
CRITIQUES OF DAVID TALLENT'S SONG
DON'T RUN AWAY
CLICK HERE TO ENTER A NEW REVIEW (CLOSED)
|
David's own comments: I have better material, but I wanna submit my "party" song...best listened to while drunk 'Course, I had to have someone kick me in the groin to get there... |
|
JUDGE |
RATING |
COMMENTS |
|
06-Alex Calvo |
5 |
Obviously you have rhythm. However, I'd lose the effects on your voice and just do your best belting it out. I don't like this kind of music however. Sorry. |
|
03-Joe Huettner |
6 |
Being a bass player, the intro rules. haha! The vocals seem to me to clash with the song. The hook/chorus is really good though. Maybe just have one low voice do the verses. |
|
09-Robert Field |
5 |
If I was in a night club I would dance to this one... But to sit and listen,....I couldn't do it.. Good beat, but too much wah on guitar for me. |
|
10-Jeremy Haynes |
6.75 |
Serious bass groove on this track, reminds me of a PFunk song. The multi-vocal effects detract a bit from what is otherwise a fun dance track. |
|
11-Joro |
5 |
The beat is great... |
|
04-Mike Tricker |
7.5 |
Liked it could dance to it. |
|
91-Christina |
5.5 |
Rocky Horror Picture Show LOL! Good beat and instrumentation and a good recording. Unfortunately no actual melody emerges. Fortunately this has the effect of showing less your vocal shortcomings, which I won't shy away from expressing, as I am only echoing your own self-assessment LOL! |
|
08-Don Lyman |
7.5 |
Fun song. Liked the beat (very danceable), instrumentation, vocals, and lyrics. But, it was hard to make out the lyrics. The vocals sounded great until the chorus. Need to keep the same vocal mix on the chorus as on the verses. Also, I think you should synch up the vocals on the chorus with the instrumentation, instead of singing in between the riffs. The vocals on the chorus would sound great if they were sung with the riffs. Good job overall. |
|
07-Nancy G. Brundrett |
9.25 |
You know I like your sound! Your music makes me forget about |
|
12-Hazelglow |
6.75 |
Have you ever thought about writing children's music? That's honestly not meant to be an insult, but I totally hear this song NOT in a dance club (it just doesn't sound like anything you would hear on the dance charts) but on The Muppet Show or similar. Animal would love to play the drums on this one - he would go off! But as an sdult song, a real song in the big bad world, I can't see it working. It's just too cute and simplistic in its structure/presentation - BUT with all these cool riffs and sounds going on here, I can see little kiddies boogeying down to it at some stage show at the mall during school holidays. I'm going to pretend you actually intend this song as a children's number, and give you a higher score based on that. Ever heard of The Wiggles? They're making millions in the kiddies' market these days (in fact they are in the top ten income earners in all of Australia, right up there with Kylie Minogue and Nicole Kidman) ever since they gave up |
|
01-Lee Alexander |
6.5 |
Overall, not a bad dance tune. I would suggest having a female do the "Don't run away" falsetto bit- or Bring it down in the mix a bit or even take it out altogether. I found it a bit annoying after the first go around. The drum sequencing in awesome and so is the instrumentation. |